10% Off Scrubs, Exfoliants, Peels for Self-Care September

BEST EYELINERS FOR SENSITIVE EYES

Here Are Our Top Picks for the Best Eyeliner for Sensitive Eyes

The best easy-to-use liquid liner for sensitive eyes

BFF Liquid liner is incredible and one of the best eyeliners for sensitive eyes overall. It is a felt tip eyeliner that is safe and easy to use has a bendy tip that slides on smoothly creating thick and thin lines without pressure and has an exceptional pigmentation in one strike without jerking or omitting something. BFF Liquid Liner is tested and approved to give you a perfect, and a sharp look all day, enhancing your eyes and making them colorful at a glance. This is a cool eyeliner product for sensitive eyes, is easy to apply, waterproof, fragrance free and comes in a variety of standard smudge-proof shades such as black and white.

The best quick to dry liquid eyeliner for sensitive eyes

Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner is one of the best eyeliners for sensitive eyes that is simple to apply, quick to dry and smudge proof no matter what. With this eyeliner, you can cry, do physical exercise that leads to sweating and it still remains intact. It has a fine felt tip and the formula glides perfectly, smoothly, and evenly creating thick, thin and more dramatic shapes. Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner comes in a variety of colors that give a unique look, beauty and feeling.

The best liquid eyeliner with a felt tip

This fragrance-free eyeliner pencil is a fabulous product from Morphe that is waterproof with a 24-hour long-wearing Felt-Tip Liquid Liner that has a great pigment formula and does not stain, disappear, or transfer. It has a stiffer tip with a steady flow that is easier to control. It is not messy and cannot get into the eye. This Felt-Tip Liquid Liner enhances the eyes by creating a continuous smooth conspicuous line.

The best eyeliner for tight lining

A Sephora Collection product whose quality is of high standards. It is a waterproof eyeliner that is uber-black in color, and an extremely thin liner that creates precision lines in just one stroke. This Fine Liner Felt-Tip Eyeliner can last for up to 12 hours and is fit for tight lining and enhances the eyes perfectly. This eyeliner pencil can be used alone or to give definition to a smokey eye. It is applied on the outer corner of the eyes to enhance the lines from the bottom of the eyes.

Eyeliner with a long-wearing effect

This Tattoo Liner is an award-winning vegan best-selling liquid eyeliner that features enhanced pigments for cloudy all-day wear that is waterproof and stain-resistant. Tattoo Liner is sure and trusted, free of chemicals, and safe for sensitive eyes. It stays put for a long time and creates every imaginable look and eye shape including iconic winged lines and more. It has an extremely precise brush tip designed for super-simple application and ultimate precision, making this tattoo liner super easy to use and the perfect tool for all skin types. Apply gently for fine exact and perfect lines and if you want to create a thicker, bold eyeliner look, then add more pressure.

The best water-resistant liquid liner

Voyeur Waterproof Liquid Liner contains a great black shade for a darker and more dramatic feel. Its flexible tip is specifically designed to give ideal control while you apply it to the skin around your eyes, safely sliding onto the lash line evenly and smoothly for enhancement every time. The Voyeur Waterproof Liquid Liner dries very fast curbing stains or transfer for all-day wear, and won’t skip or tweak when being applied. The tip is built to create thin, clear lines when you apply it to the skin around your eyes. It's bold and great for creating amazing winged eyes with an ideal ultra-black formula amount with each mark. 

The best saturated liquid eyeliner

This eyeliner is waterproof and highly saturated satin finish with an innovative bent tip and triangular grip for comfortable unending lining that lasts. The Fly liner Longwear Liquid Eyeliner provides you with all that you want in a liner for sensitive skin with a crisp intensity of liquid color. Keep in mind, it is chemical-free, has a water-resistant formula and can be worn on the skin for a long time. It's simple to use, dries quickly and won’t lose or transfer color. A good product for sensitive skin that creates fine lines, thick flips and has no limit - lining at its finest.

The best dark liquid eyeliners

This is one of the best eyeliners for sensitive skin with a real dark liquid eyeliner that creates smooth and accurate lines on the skin that are perfect for any look from a thin line to a visible cat's eye. The Roller Liner Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner has an accurate super-slide tip for sharp controlled lines and a super smooth application. It dries quickly and has a water-resistant effect formula that can last up to 24 hours and won’t lose color, peel, flow or streak. It doesn’t drag on the skin, creates a smooth constant line, and stays put all day.

The best choice of eyeliners for sensitive eyes

This eyeliner has a felt brush that is excellent and allows you to create a super outline every time even for those that are not makeup experts. It dries super-fast on your skin, is smudge-proof, and long-lasting as the liquid color slides on smoothly and lasts all day. The Bella Reina Waterproof Felt Tip Liquid Eyeliner Pen is water-resistant, with lines that are sharp, sweat-proof and long-lasting. Its tip does not falter and never breaks off plus it evenly applies the liner. It enhances the eyes perfectly by drawing accurate, clean and sharp lines. It comes in four long-lasting highly pigmented shades and is perfect for sensitive eyes.

Which is the Best Eyeliner for Sensitive Eyes?

#1. BFF Liquid Liner

This is one of the best eyeliners for sensitive eyes overall. This makeup product is safe and simple to use on all skin types, has a bendy tip that slides smoothly creating thick and thin lines without pressure and has an exceptional color in one slide without jerking. It is a cruelty free product and should be shaken well before use to ensure maximum flow. It can be paired with BFF Mascara to give you a complete look.

The BFF Liquid Liner eyeliners are tested and approved to give you a perfect, and a sharp look all day, enhancing your eyes and making them colorful at a glance. It is waterproof and comes in a variety of standard shades such as black and white. This eyeliner is waterproof and does not wear off easily.

Application

It can create thick to thin lines, sleek wing to a full-on cat's eye. It keeps you looking super sharp all day, is smudge-proof, and won’t flow or feather. It is not cruel to eyes and should be shaken well before use to ensure maximum flow. It can be paired with BFF Mascara to give you a complete look.

#2. Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner

Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner makeup is one of the top cruelty-free liners, with easy application, quick to dry, smudge-proof, and does not flow no matter what. With this eyeliner pencil, you can cry, do physical exercise that leads to sweating and still remain looking good. It has a fine tip that applies perfectly, smoothly, and evenly creating thick, thin and more dramatic bold shapes with accuracy.

The Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner comes in a variety of colors that give a unique look, beauty and feeling. When applying these eyeliners, pull gently on the upper corner of the eyes to stretch and smooth the skin around the eyes before lining with the liquid gel liner. This makes it easy to create lines and eliminate bleeding.

Application

It has a fine marker-like tip that offers you accurate application for everyone from newbies to experts. With these eyeliners, you can use the tip of the pen to create thin clean lines.

#3. Felt-Tip Liquid Liner

These eyeliners are a fabulous makeup product from Morphe that is waterproof with a 24-hour long-wearing application for sensitive skin. This smudge-proof Felt-Tip Liquid Liner has a great pigment and does not stain, smudge, disappear, or transfer. It has a stiffer tip with a steady flow of liquid that is easier to control.

Application

These eyeliners are not messy and cannot get into the eye. The Felt-Tip Liquid Liner enhances the eyes by creating continuous smooth thick or thin lines. This gel eyeliner is easy to draw on eyes and does not leave black stuff in the corner of your eyes.

#4. Fine Line Felt Tip Eyeliner

This Sephora Collection product is one of the great eyeliners whose quality is of high standards. It is a waterproof and smudge-proof eyeliner pencil that is uber-black in color, and an extremely thin liner that creates precise lines in just one stroke. This cruelty-free, ophthalmologist tested Fine Liner Felt-Tip Eyeliner can last for up to 12 hours and is fit for tight lining and enhances the eyes perfectly.

These eyeliners can be used alone or to give definition to smokey eye makeup. It is applied on the outer corners of the eyes to enhance the lines from the bottom of the contour of the eyes. The product has gone through rigorous testing for quality, traceability and safety and is safe to use throughout the day.

Application

When using to line your eyes, draw a line from the inner to the outer corner of the eye. For a super look, make a swipe at the outer corners of the eyes to extend from the bottom of the eye contour.

#5. Tattoo Liner

This is an award-winning vegan best-selling liquid eyeliner that features enhanced pigments for a cloudy look you can wear throughout the day. It is waterproof and stain-resistant. This Tattoo Liner is sure and trusted to stay put for a long time. It creates every imaginable look and every shape including iconic winged eyes and more.

Application

This cruelty-free, ophthalmologist tested liner has an extremely precise brush tip designed for super-easy application and ultimate precision, making this tattoo liner the perfect tool for all people with sensitive skin. Apply gently for fine exact and perfect lines and if you want to create a thicker, bold eyeliner look, then add more pressure.

#6. HOURGLASS Voyeur Waterproof Liquid Liner

The Voyeur Waterproof Liquid Liner for sensitive skin contains great black shade for a darker and more dramatic feel. Its flexible tip is specifically designed to give ideal control, safely sliding onto the lash line evenly and smooth for lash boosting every time. The Voyeur Waterproof Liquid Liner dries very fast curbing stain or transfer, and won’t skip or falter when being applied.

Application

Its custom tapered tip is built to create thin, clear lines, bold and visible for amazing winged eyes and deposits an ideal ultra-black formula amount with each mark. When using, gently draw the pointed tip of the pen along your lashes. Tightly secure the cap in place after each use to avoid drying out of the product. This product is ophthalmologist tested, safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.

#7. Fly liner Longwear Liquid Eyeliner

This liquid eyeliner is waterproof and has a highly saturated satin finish with an innovative bent tip and an easy grasp triangular shape for an easy lining that lasts. The Fly liner Longwear Liquid Eyeliner provides you with all that you want in a pencil eyeliner with a crisp intensity of liquid color. It has a water-resistant formula and can be worn for a long time. It dries quickly and won’t lose or transfer color.

A good liner that creates fine lines, thick flips and has no limit lining at its finest. It has a triangular shape that makes it easy to hold avoiding any eye-opening drama and stress. Its super-flex tip is an exclusive innovation that allows for smooth ink flow from every angle.

Application

This liner has a highly saturated satin finish with each and every stroke with no skipping, dragging or retracing of your steps. All shapes of eyes have been catered for with the tapered accurate point that is extra-long, with a flexible tip specifically designed for maximum versatility. This product is safe for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.

#8. Roller Liner Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

This eyeliner is a real dark liquid eyeliner that creates smooth and accurate lines that are perfect for creating any look from a thin line to a visible cat eye. The Roller Liner Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner has an accurate easy-slide tip for sharp controlled lines and a super smooth application.

Application

It dries quickly and has a waterproof formula that can last up to 24 hours and won’t lose color, peel, flow or streak. It doesn’t drag on the skin, creates smooth constant lines and stays put all day every day.

#9. Bella Reina Waterproof Felt Tip Liquid Eyeliner Pen

This eyeliner has a felt tip brush that is excellent and allows you to create super precise lines every time even for those that are not makeup experts. It dries super-fast and is long-lasting as the liquid color slides on smoothly and lasts all day. The Bella Reina Waterproof Felt Tip Liquid Eyeliner Pen is water-resistant, with lines that are sharp, sweat-proof and long-lasting. One of the best eyeliners overall.

Its tip does not flicker and never breaks off, plus the formula glides evenly when applied. This product enhances the eyes perfectly by drawing accurate, clean and sharp lines. It comes in four long-lasting highly pigmented shades and is perfect for sensitive eyes.

Application

The felt tip draws clean sharp smudge free lines, plus the tip does not shake or break off ever. It comes in four long-lasting, highly pigmented, popular makeup shades such as purple, black, and brown. The colors are shown on each pen at the end of the pen for easy access in your makeup bag.

It is easy to remove when you wash off with vegan makeup remover. This eyeliner is not irritating, perfect for sensitive eyes contact lens wearers, and free of allergens.

Best Eyeliner for Sensitive Eyes – FAQ

Which eyeliner is best for eyes?

The best choice for eyes is the gel type. Gel eyeliners are accurate with a consistency that is thicker than liquid liners and its formula is creamy. Gel eyeliner comes in a tiny pot and should be applied with a brush.

Gel eyeliner is a great option that makes your eyes pop, it gives you a look that stays put and is not easy to peel off once set.

What is the best eyeliner that stays on all day?

The best product that stays on all day is the Tarteist Double Take Eyeliner which has a double-ended eyeliner with both a waterproof formula and pencil liner integrated into one efficient tool. It has a liquid on one end and a gel pencil on the other. This useful tool enables you to draw any lines you want without switching the pencil.

It features ingredients that are perfectly natural and free of chemicals, allergy tested, for better, longer use. It also contains mineral pigments that soften and soothe the skin around the lash line. This eyeliner is vegan and free of gluten.

The Tarteist Double Take Eyeliner is a two-in-one long-wear gel and liquid eyeliner that makes a wide range of eyes look great. The clay infused gel pen slides along the inner edge of the eyes to enhance them perfectly while the liquid eyeliner applies glossy and dries to a matte, opaque finish. The flexible soft tip settles a uniform, saturated pigment, perfect for ultra-fine lines or a crisp cat eye look.

Is it okay to put eyeliner in your eye?

It is not okay to put eyeliner inside the lash line as it can directly interfere with the eyes introducing bacteria. Eyeliners have some small particles that can contaminate the eyes if applied inside the eyelid. When you line your eyes, it should be applied to the outer part of the eyes only.

A number of people wear eyeliner on the inner part of their eyes or on the waterline because to them eyeliner is vital to define the contours of the eyes. The water lines are found above the lashes on the lower eyelid and below the lashes on the upper eyelid. When you use this technique the eye appears more boldly enhanced than with other methods.

It is dangerous to apply eyeliner on the waterline because it can be a threat to your eyes. When the eyeliner sticks to the lenses, it increases an accumulation which in turn leads to vision problems as the lens turns more cloudy. Applying eyeliner in your eye has serious side effects as it can damage the surface of the eye in the process.

Eyeliner can damage your eyes and can lead to irritation, swelling or even infection if applied regularly. Avoid adding eyeliner to your waterline.

How do you put eyeliner around your eye?

You can put eyeliner around your eye using a pencil eyeliner and the process of applying it can be stressful. For some people with sensitive eyes, eyeliner application can poke the eyes, some smudge while others slip causing havoc. There are ways of applying eyeliners perfectly without causing any harm to your eyes.

Place the eyeliner tip as close to your lash line as possible. To create a smooth line, hold your finger to make the skin around your eye tight but make sure you do not pull. By pulling the skin you can make it wrinkle and your line will not be smooth.

Point your chin up while looking down so that your lids are half-closed though you can still see them in the mirror. Once you are in position, draw short dashes along your top lash line starting with the inner corner of your eye.

What's the best eyeliner for mature eyes?

The best product for mature eyes should include vitamin E to help keep the skin supple. Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner by Stila has a tiny, marker-like option, is user-friendly, attractive and provides great appearance either using a thin outline or an enhancing visible mark. It is easy to apply, dries quickly and remains intact.

It is the easiest to apply and it goes on simply without smudging or dragging and does not smudge. When applying, you start at the area of the eye where the brush naturally falls. For right-handed women, this is a left to right motion and for left-handed women, it is a right to left motion.

This eyeliner is the best product for creating an amazing cat eye which is achieved by expanding the eye shape.

What is Important When We Are Looking for The Best Eyeliner for Sensitive Eyes?

When looking for a perfect eyeliner you have to keep in mind some considerations:

Pencil

Pencil eyeliners are the most popular type of eyeliner used by more than half of the women. It is easier to apply than liquid because it is safe to deal with in case you make a mistake. Use it on the upper lid and inner waterline if you want a smokey eye or lash boosting effect.

Liquid

You need intense and rich colors which you should get by applying pigment through a saturated sponge tip. The liner should be well shaken before use to get a more regular color application. Liquid liners have a super-accurate application but make sure you use it on the upper lids and not on your waterline.

Gel

With a gel eyeliner, you need a specific brush to apply this formula which comes in a tiny pot. Newer gels have been improved and they come in twist-up, and push-up applicator packaging. It has a stable pencil with all the colors of liquid liners.

Colors

Consider the colors of the eyeliner you prefer before buying one. Neutral colors can be worn any day but if you want more impacting colors for special occasions, then you need to choose one that will stand out. Go for your natural eye color if you are not sure about the shade you want.

Water-resistance

The best thing with waterproof eyeliner is that it does not spot or peel. You can remove it using a waterproof makeup remover. Water-resistant eyeliners work well in humid or rainy areas and can also be a great choice if you have contact lenses or if your eyes keep watering.

Vitamin E

For older women, vitamin E is essential for healthy skin and can help combat the effects of aging around the eyes. Any makeup product with vitamin E as one of the main ingredients should be a priority before color or other considerations.